M/M romance

The New Guy

This m/m romance is often discussed for flat characters, predictable plot and weak plot.

* Amazon affiliate link. A purchase may earn us a commission without changing your price.

The quick read

Know the vibe before you commit

This m/m romance is often discussed for flat characters, predictable plot and weak plot.

Pairing
M/M
Setting
Sports Romance
Dynamic
M/M romance
Heat

4/5 — Explicit open door

Pace
Not specified
Biggest divide
Predictable Plot
Decision guide for Is The New Guy your next read?: Best fit: Sports romance; Best fit: Likable lead; Check first: Flat characters; Related read: Tigers and Devils
Compare likely fit and cautions before opening the full book profile.

The conversation around this book

What people talk about

These themes can help you judge the fit. They are not a rating or a promise that everyone will have the same experience.

What tends to work

Flat Characters

Gavin is unrealistically perfect for a twenty-five-year-old widowed parent with a demanding medical career, making him feel implausible.

Predictable Plot

The plot is familiar and the third-act crisis is telegraphed well in advance, though the journey remains enjoyable.

Weak Plot

Conflict is fairly minimal and familial conflict resolutions happen off-page, which feels anticlimactic.

What may not work for you

No clear recurring theme stands out for this section.

Keep the feeling

Books with a similar fit

Find a closer match

M/M romance

Tigers and Devils

Sean Kennedy

Matches on Sports Romance, Likable Lead, Tender.

See why it matches

M/M romance

Us

Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy

Matches on Sports Romance, Explicit Heat, Humorous.

See why it matches

M/M romance

Shattered Glass

Dani Alexander

Matches on Likable Lead, Explicit Heat, Strong Chemistry.

See why it matches

Your call

Ready for The New Guy?

Check the current edition, or find a book that better matches the reading experience you want.